Making the decision to do a review of the macarons at Ladurée seems sacrilegious. Who am I to judge the oldest, most established, and one of the most respected macaron makers in the world? But trying them opened my eyes to two important points. One, if I’m going to be really good at these, I’m going to have to learn the chemistry. Two, there’s room in the market for different schools of thought on what should go into a macaron. (Note that most of these comments will focus on the fillings of the macarons, as the shells at Ladurée vary only in color, as far as I could tell. No embellishments, no lustre dust. Nada.)

Okay, here we go! In order of preference.
Raisin & cannelle – This translates literally to grape and cinnamon. It was my absolute favorite. The base of the filling is thick and creamy, like a white chocolate ganache, but without the flavor of white chocolate. It was strong and complex, with really nice floral undertones. Absolutely amazing.
Pistache – Again, absolutely delicious. The filling was intense and creamy. My guess is that they whipped a good amount of pistachio paste into butter and confectioners sugar. The pistachios are a very fine grind, but till noticeable. I love the texture.
Citron (Lemon) – Ahh, the tart & sour. This macaron is absolutely delicious, but I know they couldn’t have achieved that zing without the tart additive, and I’m torn here because that’s what makes it incredible. Lemon curd mixed into buttercream for the filling. Delightful.
Chocolat – Holy wonderful bittersweet ganache, Batman! This was a great lesson for me, because in the past when I’ve made chocolate ganache it’s been incredibly thick. Too thick. This ganache is like the filling of a very high quality truffle. What’s the difference between theirs and mine? 100% cacao? Glucose? Egg yolk? Technique? This one is going to drive me crazy.
Caramel à la fleur de sel (Salted caramel) - I’m torn here. I love the way I make my caramel macarons. I think the combination of caramel sauce and caramel buttercream is really nice. This macaron was filled with a thick layer of caramel that had a consistency right in between a sauce and a soft candy. It pulled just a tiny bit when you took a bite, but never dripped. Just enough burnt sugar flavor, just enough butter. Not enough salt for me, but that’s just a personal preference. I like some crunch in my salted caramel.
Noix de coco (Coconut) – The filling of this one is just like the inside of a Mounds bar. I’m thinking shredded coconut mixed with condensed milk and confectioners sugar. Soft and chewy.
Framboise (Raspberry) – The jam in this has a great texture. It is not so wet that it soaks through the macaron. It has a little bit of raspberry seed in it, which I like. It’s also a great balance between tart and sweet. If you’re going to fill a macaron with jam, this is definitely the way to do it.
Vanille – I know a lot of people who love this type of macaron, but I prefer a vanilla bean buttercream to ganache. (See my previous post from 5/22/11. I won’t rehash it.) However, this macaron had a very interesting floral undertone that I couldn’t quite figure out. Very interesting.
Pétale de rose (Rose petal) – My husband and I are in complete disagreement over this flavor. It was one of his top three. The scent of rose hit you before anything else. I liked it enough. On a technical note, this was the point where we noticed the distinct lack of sweetness across the board. I mean, there’s obviously a certain amount of sugar that has to be used to make a macaron, but none of the fillings were overly sweet. The essence of rose was definitely the star.
Cassis violette (Blackcurrant & violet) – I liked that the consistency of this was very thick, almost like the texture of fig paté. A bit tart for me, and I have to admit that I expected a more complex flavor from this combination. I just couldn’t identify the violet.
Fleur d’Oranger (Orange blossom) – This one smells amazing. I wish it tasted as amazing as it smells. You immediately get white chocolate from the ganache, then a little note of floral, but it’s just such a delicate flavor it gets lost in the ganache. I wish they had used buttercream.
Pomme verte (Green apple) – White chocolate ganache base, sour apple Jolly Rancher flavor. An incredible intensity that does not occur in nature. If I could have gotten past that fact I probably would have loved it, but I couldn’t and I didn’t.
Fraise mentholée (Strawberry mint) – Oh, my dear friends at Ladurée, there are so many varieties of mint out there. How did you manage to find the one that tastes the most like toothpaste? Is this spearmint extract mixed into strawberry jam? Yuck. I tossed the rest of it out the car window.
Café (Coffee) – I can’t believe this was my least favorite! If I took a cupcake from your average bargain grocery store, scraped off the grainy frosting and mixed in espresso powder, I’d have the filling for this macaron. It was the worst of the bunch. You too, little guy. Out the window you go.

Overall, here are my two lessons from the experience:
1) Pierre Hermé is the pastry chef who revolutionized the macaron while working at Ladurée. I have relied heavily on his cookbook for the past nine months, but after gaining more experience and my visit to Ladurée, I know there are bits of info that are missing. I’m at the point where I really need to understand the chemistry behind what I do. If anyone knows of a comprehensive online resource for this stuff, I’d love to know.
2) There’s an abundant use of artificial flavors in Ladurée’s macarons, particularly tart & sour flavor enhancer. In some of the macarons, it really gives them a spark they wouldn’t have otherwise. In others, it’s so obvious to me the flavor is artificial that I can’t appreciate it. Rhetorical, I suppose. I’ll let you be the judge.